Tarrytown’s October 2026 single-family report rests on one closed sale. That single closing produced a reported median of $599,900, “down 61%,” and an average of 141 days on market, “up 271%.” Neither percentage says anything about what a Tarrytown house is worth. Read alone, it is the kind of headline that ends up in a buyout letter or an executor’s email. This post shows why that is a problem, and which Tarrytown figures do hold up.
This November 2026 Insights post reads the latest closed-sale statistics the way an appraiser does: price level, inventory, days on market (DOM), sale-to-list, and closed volume, with no lifestyle framing. It complements the methodology piece Appraising Homes in Tarrytown, NY and does not replace a property-specific assignment. Local coverage is described on the firm’s Tarrytown appraisal page and the Westchester County appraiser hub.
Sources: Three public series are used below. The primary is the Houlihan Lawrence Tarrytown Single Family Monthly Market Report for October 2026 (OneKey MLS). The second is the William Pitt Sotheby’s Tarrytown Market Tracker for October 2026. The third is the Homix OneKey-based Tarrytown report for October 2026 (data as of November 8, 2026), used here for its trailing 12-month series. Each provider draws “Tarrytown” its own way, so the counts differ. Appraisers reconcile competing series by reading the filter first, then the number, and by verifying current MLS closed sales for the assignment’s effective date.
October 2026: Tarrytown Single-Family Snapshot
Houlihan Lawrence’s Tarrytown single-family table for October 2026 shows:
- Median sale price: $599,900 (−60.0% versus September 2026; −61.3% versus October 2025)
- Average sale price: $599,900 (−69.4% MoM; −61.6% YoY)
- Units sold: 1 (−66.7% MoM; −85.7% YoY)
- Average DOM: 141 days (+51.6% MoM; +271.1% YoY)
- Sale-to-list (% of sales price): 100.00% (−0.6% MoM; −6.6% YoY)
- Units for sale: 4 (−42.9% MoM; −50.0% YoY)
- Months of inventory: 4.00 (+73.9% MoM; +263.6% YoY)
When median and average are the same number, only one sale closed. Every percentage above compares that one house to a different mix of houses a month or a year earlier. The 4.00 months of inventory is a similar artifact: four listings divided by a one-sale month. The ten-year table in the same report is more useful. Through October 31, 2026, it lists a 2026 year-to-date median sold price of $1,205,000 on 37 single-family sales. That is about 4.8% above the 2025 full-year median of $1,150,000, which was itself a 30% jump over 2024’s $883,000. The 2017 median on that table was $695,000, so the 2026 YTD figure is roughly 73% higher. Volume reads lower: 37 sales through ten months, against 52 for all of 2025 and 40 in 2024.
| Metric (Tarrytown SF, HL / OneKey) | Oct 2026 | vs Sep 2026 | vs Oct 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $599,900 | −60.0% | −61.3% |
| Average sale price | $599,900 | −69.4% | −61.6% |
| Units sold | 1 | −66.7% | −85.7% |
| Average DOM | 141 days | +51.6% | +271.1% |
| Sale-to-list | 100.00% | −0.6% | −6.6% |
| Units for sale | 4 | −42.9% | −50.0% |
| Months of inventory | 4.00 | +73.9% | +263.6% |
| 2026 YTD median (thru 10/31) | $1,205,000 | 2025 full year: $1,150,000 (+4.8%) | |
| 2026 YTD units sold (thru 10/31) | 37 | 2025 full year: 52 | |
Source: Houlihan Lawrence Tarrytown Single Family Monthly Market Report, October 2026 (OneKey MLS), including its ten-year market history table. Figures deemed reliable but not guaranteed; not a value opinion for any subject property.
In Tarrytown, October 2026 closed one single-family sale. A one-sale month can show a 61% price “drop” and a 271% DOM “jump” without any house losing value. For a date-of-death or divorce valuation, the defensible evidence is the trailing year and the matched sales, not the October headline.
William Pitt Tracker: Same One Sale, Wider Lens
William Pitt Sotheby’s Tarrytown Market Tracker for October 2026 uses a wider Tarrytown reporting area. Its single-family line shows the same one-sale month, and its other product types show where most Tarrytown volume actually is:
- Units sold (October, SF): 1 (−85.7% versus October 2025; −75.0% versus October 2024)
- Median and average sold (SF): about $600,000 (median −61.3% YoY and −21.0% versus October 2024; average −61.6% YoY and −21.5% versus October 2024)
- Average DOM (SF): 141 (+266.9% YoY; +548.3% versus October 2024)
- Percentage of asking (SF): 86% (−18.8% YoY; −18.4% versus October 2024)
- Average $/SF (SF): $272 (−55.2% YoY; −39.1% versus October 2024)
- New SF listings (October): 2 (−33.3% YoY; −50.0% versus October 2024)
- Condo/co-op sales (October): 8 (+14.3% YoY), including 7 condos
- YTD sold (January–October 2026): 32 single-family (−20.0% versus YTD 2025) and 93 condo/co-op (+31.0%), of which 79 were condos (+46.3%) and 14 co-ops (−17.6%)
- Total monthly inventory (all product types): 70 units (+16.7% YoY; +1.4% versus October 2024)
Source: William Pitt Sotheby’s Tarrytown Market Tracker (October 2026). Brokerage dashboard figures are deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Two points matter for valuation. First, HL reports the October sale at 100% of list while William Pitt shows 86% of asking for the same month. Trackers measure against different list prices (last list versus original asking) and do not always state which one they use. On a one-sale month, that difference can be the whole story of a single price cut. Second, attached product outsold detached homes nearly three to one year to date on William Pitt’s count. A Tarrytown “market” figure that blends condos with houses describes neither one.
Homix 12-Month Series: The Numbers Worth Quoting
Homix’s OneKey-based Tarrytown report covers October 2026 (data as of November 8, 2026). Its single-family month also shows one closing, but a different one: $710,000, 27 days on market, 102.2% of original list. That is the boundary question again. The trailing 12-month columns are the useful part:
| Metric (Homix, Tarrytown SF) | 12 mo. thru Oct 2025 | 12 mo. thru Oct 2026 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Closed sales | 37 | 36 | −2.7% |
| Median sale price | $1,030,000 | $909,000 | −11.7% |
| % of original list | 105.3% | 107.5% | +2.1% |
| Average DOM | 75 | 36 | −52.0% |
| New listings | 58 | 43 | −25.9% |
| Average homes for sale | 11 | 6 | −45.5% |
Source: Homix Tarrytown market report, October 2026, calculated from OneKey MLS data. Homix also reports about 1.3 months of single-family supply, 75% of sales closing above original list over 12 months, and the $750K–$1M band accounting for 31% of sales.
On this series, Tarrytown single-family supply is tight: average listings nearly halved, new listings fell by about a quarter, and three of four sales closed above original list. DOM was cut in half. Volume was flat at 36 sales. Price is the one metric where the series disagree. Homix shows the 12-month median down 11.7% to $909,000. Houlihan Lawrence shows a 2026 YTD median of $1,205,000, up 4.8%. Both are built from OneKey MLS data. Different boundaries and a 36-to-37-sale sample are enough to put the medians about $300,000 apart. That gap is a mix-and-boundary effect, not proof that values moved in either direction.
Homix’s Tarrytown condo series is the larger, steadier sample: 53 closings in each 12-month window, a 12-month median of $655,000 (−1.9% from $668,000), sales at 101.1% of original list (down from 103.1%), and average condo inventory up from 8 to 11 (14 for sale in October, about 3.2 months of supply). Attached product is roughly flat on price with more supply. Detached product is tight on supply with no clear direction on price.
Why Tarrytown Headlines Mislead
- One sale is not a market: “−61%” and “+271%” compare a single October closing to seven a year earlier. When one house is the whole sample, the percentage reflects which house sold, not a change in value.
- Boundaries change the answer: HL, William Pitt, and Homix each report a different October sale or a different YTD count (37, 32, and 36 over trailing 12 months). Confirm the subject is inside the area the statistic describes before quoting it.
- The medians disagree; the supply data does not: Every series shows low single-family inventory and sale-to-list near or above 100% over the year. Those are the stable facts. The direction of the median is not settled by any one source.
- Months of supply needs a real denominator: HL’s 4.00 months is four listings over one sale. Homix’s 1.3 months uses a 12-month sales rate and is the better read of current absorption.
- Detached and attached are different markets: With condos and co-ops making up roughly three-quarters of William Pitt’s YTD Tarrytown single-family plus condo/co-op sales, a blended figure is mostly a condo figure.
For a deeper primer on how appraisers parse medians, months of supply, DOM, and sale-to-list, see Market Conditions and How Appraisers Analyze the Stats. For a nearby comparison on a larger single-family sample, see the Ardsley housing market 2026 update.
How Appraisers Read Tarrytown’s Competitive Sets
Market-conditions commentary in a Tarrytown appraisal is built from the sales that actually compete with the subject, not from the area headline alone.
- Confirm the location first: Village of Tarrytown, or a Tarrytown mailing address outside the village (the 10591 ZIP code also takes in Sleepy Hollow and unincorporated sections). Taxing jurisdiction and municipal services can differ, so pull comps inside the matching set before expanding to Sleepy Hollow, Irvington, or Briarcliff Manor sales.
- Expand time before expanding geography: With about three single-family closings a month, an appraiser often reaches back 12 months or more inside Tarrytown before crossing a village line. The report should explain the choice.
- Measure location influences, don’t assume them: Hudson River views, frontage on Route 9 or Route 119, and proximity to the I-87/I-287 corridor and the Metro-North line are tested with paired sales where the data supports it. See how proximity factors are tested in Westchester.
- Time adjustments from the matched set: With one series showing a −11.7% trailing median and another showing +4.8% YTD, a supported time adjustment comes from paired and repeat sales in the subject’s price and quality band, not from either headline.
- Condo and co-op product is separate: Tarrytown’s large condo segment is analyzed within its own complexes and competing attached product, with association fees and project data. It is not a basis for a detached single-family conclusion, and vice versa.
- Assessment versus market value: Assessed value is not market value. Tax-grievance work compares the assessment to a current, supportable market-value opinion. See tax grievance appraisals.
Estate, Date-of-Death, and Divorce Files on a Thin-Sample Market
Thin markets are where AVMs and area medians are least reliable, and where the effective date carries the most weight. For files that must stand up for counsel or a fiduciary:
- Estate / date-of-death: A retrospective opinion for Form 706, the New York estate tax return, probate, or fiduciary accounting uses market evidence knowable as of the date of death. Quoting October 2026’s $599,900 “median” for a Tarrytown date of death earlier in 2026 would mix effective dates and rely on a single sale. Depending on which house closed, the error could go either way. See estate appraisal, date-of-death appraisal, and date of death vs current market value.
- Divorce / equitable distribution: Current or retrospective (including date-of-commencement) valuations of the marital residence. In Tarrytown 2026, one spouse can cite an 11.7% median decline and the other a 4.8% gain, both from OneKey MLS. The effective date and the matched set decide the number, not either headline. See divorce appraisal and date-of-commencement appraisals in NY divorce.
- Attorney and fiduciary briefing: Counsel often need a plain-English read of whether a proposed buyout or listing price is consistent with recent matched sales, not with the area median or an AVM alone. Private USPAP reports differ from lender forms. See private vs lender appraisals and the firm’s attorney resources.
What Helps a Tarrytown Market-Conditions Read
- Confirm Village of Tarrytown vs a Tarrytown mailing address elsewhere, and whether each data filter matches that area
- Count the sales behind any monthly statistic before quoting a percentage change
- Pull closed MLS sales that match the subject’s location, GLA band, condition, view, and lot size and utility
- Record list price, original list price, sale price, concessions, and DOM for each competing sale
- Use trailing 12-month data, not a single month, before supporting any time adjustment
- Note active and pending inventory inside the subject’s price and quality band, not only the area total
- Keep detached single-family, condo, and co-op sales in separate data sets
Final Thoughts
As of the October 2026 reports, Tarrytown’s single-family market is tight on supply and firm on sale-to-list, with volume roughly flat to lower and no settled direction on price. Homix shows about 1.3 months of supply, 107.5% of original list, and a 36-day average DOM over the trailing year. Houlihan Lawrence’s YTD median is $1,205,000 on 37 sales, while Homix’s 12-month median is $909,000 on 36. The October “−61%” headline is one sale. Those facts describe market conditions. They do not price any one house.
A defensible Tarrytown appraisal still starts with physical evidence and matched sales from the right side of the village line. That set is then placed against the area statistics as context. Whether the purpose is estate settlement, divorce, tax grievance, or a private purchase opinion, Madison & Park builds the analysis that way across Westchester, Manhattan, and Greenwich CT. Dave Lister, SRA, is a New York certified residential appraiser and is Licensed in Connecticut; Court Approved status applies in New York only.
Hero photo: Tarrytown Light on the Hudson River, by Acroterion, via Wikimedia Commons, released under CC BY-SA 4.0; cropped and resized.
Need an Appraisal in Tarrytown?
Whether for estate planning, divorce, tax grievance, or a private market opinion, we provide thorough, professional valuation services across Westchester, Manhattan, and Greenwich CT.
Get a Free Quote